Last month at the vintage camper rally we met a very nice lady who was sharing a plate of her homemade molasses cookies. These were one of the best molasses cookies I’ve ever had. And without hesitation I asked her if she’d share her recipe. Lucky for me she did!
I made a batch of cookies using her recipe and this is how they turned out. Thick and soft, more cake like, and mildly molasses flavored – delish.
My cookie recipe (cookies pictured below) is considerably different than hers. Mine are semi-soft, chewy, and have a slightly stronger molasses flavor – delish.
There are a couple obvious differences between her recipe and mine. One is the amount of flour used. My recipe calls for two cups of flour and hers calls for seven cups. Her recipe required refrigerating the dough, and mine does not. I generally get about 2.5 dozen cookies from my batch. Her recipe yielded dozens of cookies. So many, that I stopped counting. Might I add, that my freezer is happily full of cookies now.
How’s a girl to choose between the two great recipes like these? Both cookies have great qualities. I doubt I could pass up either cookie in an independent taste test… I can tell there is going to be trouble on the horizon when it’s time to make molasses cookies in this house again.
9 thoughts on “Through Thick and Thin”
My grandmother used to make these jumbo molasses cookies that I could only eat when they were hot. I’m not a dry cookie person. I’m going to try your recipe!
Awwww, yum! My sister adores my Grandma’s molasses cookies, they are pretty delicious for sure:-) Love your recipe! Hugs, Terra
P.S. D covets that coffee tin. 🙂
Love molasses cookies and have not made them for so long. Great inspiration to do so!
Wow. They look sooo good!
And could you please share your recipe with me for your peanut butter frosting? Thank you!
They look delicious.
Don’t choose, just have them all. Where did you find the Maxwell House coffee tin?
A friend of mine gave it to me years ago. She knows I’m a fan of vintage things. It’s in beautiful shape.
Mmmm…molasses cookies, there is no right answer, they’re all good!